13 Unsolved Mysteries That Still Divide Experts

1. The Voynich Manuscript

PICRYL

The Voynich Manuscript looks like a medieval book filled with strange plants, star charts and elegant handwritten text. The problem is that no one can actually read a single word of it. Linguists, cryptographers and historians have spent decades trying to decode the language, if it even is a real language at all. Some experts believe it is an elaborate code hiding meaningful information.

Others argue it could be a clever hoax created to impress wealthy buyers of rare books. Computer programs have analyzed the patterns and found that the writing behaves somewhat like real human languages. Even with modern technology, no translation has ever been universally accepted. The manuscript remains locked behind its own mysterious alphabet. Until someone cracks it for good, the arguments are likely to continue.

2. What Really Happened at Dyatlov Pass

PICRYL

In 1959, nine experienced hikers died under bizarre circumstances in the Ural Mountains of Russia. Their tent was found slashed open from the inside, and several bodies showed unusual injuries. Some were missing eyes and tongues, which immediately fueled wild theories. For years, experts debated whether an avalanche, military testing or something more mysterious was responsible.

Modern investigations suggest a rare type of snow slide may explain the scene. Other researchers insist the evidence does not fully match that conclusion. Weather conditions, radiation traces and odd clothing choices keep the case confusing. Every few years a new theory appears claiming to solve everything. None has convinced all specialists, and the tragedy still sparks heated disagreement.

3. The True Identity of Jack the Ripper

PICRYL

The murders committed in London in 1888 are among the most famous crimes in history. Despite endless books and documentaries, the killer was never caught. Over the years, suspects have included doctors, artists and even members of the royal family. Each theory has passionate supporters who believe the mystery is already solved.

Professional historians and criminologists are far less certain. The police files are incomplete and much of the evidence was poorly handled by modern standards. New DNA tests have been proposed, but many experts doubt they can ever be definitive. More than a century later, the name Jack the Ripper still divides researchers into rival camps. A final answer may simply no longer be possible.

4. The Secrets of the Bermuda Triangle

Shutterstock

Ships and airplanes have disappeared for generations in the region known as the Bermuda Triangle. Some writers blame strange magnetic fields or sudden time warps. Others think the area is no more dangerous than any other busy stretch of ocean. Scientists point out that many famous disappearances have reasonable explanations.

Bad weather, human error and mechanical failure account for most incidents. Skeptics argue that the legend grew because dramatic stories sell well. Believers counter that a few cases remain genuinely puzzling. Charts and statistics are interpreted in very different ways depending on who is doing the research. The triangle continues to inspire debate between mystery lovers and practical investigators.

5. The Authenticity of the Shroud of Turin

PICRYL

The Shroud of Turin is a linen cloth that appears to show the image of a crucified man. Many Christians believe it is the actual burial cloth of Jesus. Scientific testing in the 1980s dated the fabric to the Middle Ages, which seemed to settle the question. That result should have ended the discussion, but it did not.

Critics argue that the sample tested may have come from a repaired section of the cloth. New imaging techniques have produced conflicting interpretations about how the image was formed. Art historians, chemists and theologians often reach very different conclusions. Supporters insist the shroud contains details impossible for a medieval forger to create. Decades of research have only deepened the divide among experts.

6. The Disappearance of the Roanoke Colony

PICRYL

In the late 1500s, an English settlement in North Carolina vanished without a clear trace. When a supply ship finally returned, the colonists were gone and the word Croatoan was carved into a post. Some historians think the settlers joined a nearby Native American tribe to survive. Others believe disease, starvation or conflict wiped them out.

Archaeologists continue to search the region for physical evidence. A few artifacts have been found, but none provide a definite answer. Written records from the period are frustratingly vague and incomplete. Each new discovery is interpreted differently by competing researchers. The fate of the so called Lost Colony remains one of early America’s biggest question marks.

7. Why Stonehenge Was Built

Shutterstock

Stonehenge has stood on the English countryside for thousands of years, yet its true purpose is still uncertain. The massive stones clearly required incredible effort and planning to erect. Some archaeologists believe it was an ancient astronomical calendar aligned with the sun. Others think it served mainly as a religious or ceremonial center.

Newer theories suggest it may have been a place of healing or pilgrimage. Excavations around the site continue to reveal surprising details about the people who built it. Even with advanced dating tools, experts cannot agree on a single explanation. Each generation of researchers proposes a fresh interpretation. The giant stone circle keeps its original intention frustratingly hidden.

8. The Meaning of the Nazca Lines

Shutterstock

Across the desert of Peru are enormous drawings of animals, shapes and straight lines carved into the ground. They are so large that many can only be seen clearly from the air. Some researchers think the lines were created as part of religious rituals honoring the gods. Others argue they marked underground water sources or ancient pathways.

A few imaginative theories even claim the figures were designed for visitors from the sky. Most scientists dismiss those ideas, but they show how wide the debate can be. New drone photography has revealed even more hidden designs in recent years. Each discovery raises fresh questions instead of settling old ones. The purpose of the Nazca Lines is still a lively academic argument.

9. The Vanishing of Amelia Earhart

PICRYL

In 1937, famed pilot Amelia Earhart disappeared while attempting to fly around the world. The official story says her plane ran out of fuel and crashed into the Pacific Ocean. Many investigators accept that explanation as the most logical. Yet other researchers believe she may have landed on a remote island and survived for a time.

Bones and artifacts found on Nikumaroro Island have been examined repeatedly with mixed results. Some experts think the evidence matches Earhart, while others say it clearly does not. A few fringe theories even suggest she was captured by Japanese forces. Modern searches continue to scan the ocean floor for wreckage. The lack of solid proof keeps the disagreement very much alive.

10. The Cause of the Tunguska Explosion

PICRYL

In 1908, a massive blast flattened millions of trees in a remote part of Siberia. The explosion was stronger than most nuclear bombs, yet no clear impact crater was found. Most scientists believe a meteor or comet exploded in the atmosphere. That explanation fits much of the physical evidence discovered later.

A smaller group of researchers argues that unusual natural gas eruptions could have caused the damage. Others have suggested exotic possibilities such as mini black holes or unknown physics. Because the event happened in such an isolated area, reliable data is limited. More than a century later, specialists still debate the exact details. Tunguska remains one of the strangest natural disasters ever recorded.

11. The Uncaught Zodiac Killer

Shutterstock

During the late 1960s and early 1970s, a serial killer terrorized Northern California and taunted police with coded letters. The case produced several strong suspects but never a confirmed arrest. Amateur sleuths constantly claim they have identified the culprit. Professional investigators are far more cautious about declaring a solution.

Recent attempts to decode the killer’s messages have provided intriguing clues. Even so, none of the evidence has been strong enough to convince everyone. DNA technology has helped solve many old crimes, but the Zodiac material is difficult to test. Each new theory seems promising for a moment and then falls apart. The killer’s true identity remains officially unknown.

12. How Easter Island’s Moai Were Moved

Shutterstock

Easter Island is famous for its huge stone statues known as moai. The ancient Polynesian people who carved them had no metal tools or large animals. This raises the obvious question of how such heavy figures were transported across the island. Some experts think the statues were rolled on logs like giant sleds.

Others believe they were rocked forward using ropes in a walking motion. Archaeological experiments have supported both ideas in different ways. Local oral traditions provide hints, but not a complete answer. Because the original builders left no written records, researchers must rely on educated guesses. The true method remains a friendly but intense scholarly debate.

13. The Oak Island Money Pit

Flickr

For more than two centuries, treasure hunters have searched a small island off the coast of Nova Scotia. Early diggers discovered a deep shaft with strange wooden platforms and rumored booby traps. Many believe the site hides pirate treasure or lost historical documents. Skeptical engineers say the pit is likely a natural sinkhole misinterpreted by hopeful explorers.

Expeditions have spent fortunes trying to reach whatever lies at the bottom. Each discovery is hailed as proof by believers and dismissed by critics. Television programs and books keep public interest alive year after year. Despite all the effort, no confirmed treasure has ever been recovered. The mystery of Oak Island continues to sharply divide opinion among experts.

Scroll to Top