11 Toys Every Girl Wanted in the ’90s That Defined the ‘It’ Crowd

1. Tamagotchi: The Digital Pet You Couldn’t Put Down

Wikimedia Commons

If you were a girl in the ’90s, there was no escaping the Tamagotchi craze. Now the New York Post confirms that the little creatures are back and better than ever! This digital pet was a must-have for anyone who wanted to be part of the “It” crowd. It was simple: just a tiny egg-shaped device with a screen that showed a virtual pet you had to feed, play with, and clean up after. However, if you forgot about it for too long, your pet would “die” and you’d have to start all over again. The stakes were high—those little creatures had feelings, and you were their lifeline! In a way, owning a Tamagotchi was almost like a rite of passage, a symbol that you could juggle responsibility while living in the exciting, high-tech world of the ’90s.

The more you took care of your Tamagotchi, the more it evolved, making it an addictive process. Everyone you knew would check their Tamagotchi regularly during class, at lunch, or while hanging out at the mall. It became a secret competitive game—who had the most evolved pet? Whether it was a little alien or a cute animal, these pets were a window into the digital future that was just beginning to take shape. Despite being so simple, the Tamagotchi provided a surprising amount of joy and anxiety. If you lost it, you’d feel like you’d lost a friend. It was the perfect mix of virtual and real-world connection that made it unforgettable.

2. Polly Pocket: Tiny Fun, Big Impact

Flickr

Polly Pocket was the original compact playset that every ’90s girl adored. These miniature dolls and their tiny worlds were housed in a small, portable case, making them easy to carry around. The sets included everything from houses to castles, all with intricate, movable pieces like beds, chairs, and tiny accessories. There was something magical about opening up a tiny world where Polly could live out her dreams, all while fitting into your pocket. The portability made it a go-to toy for long car rides or sleepovers where you could share your miniatures with friends and see who could create the best scenarios.

It wasn’t just about the doll, though. The tiny world of Polly Pocket sparked creativity, as you could create stories and adventures for her in any setting. The detail in each set was astounding for its size, and it made you feel like a master architect. The miniature accessories, especially the little furniture, felt like treasure. Because they were so small, losing pieces became part of the fun. You would spend hours searching for the missing chair or combing through your other Polly sets to find the perfect accessory. The versatility of Polly Pocket was what truly made it stand out, and it was the toy that every ’90s girl wanted in her collection. There was a Polly Pocket movie in the works but Vulture shared that it was no longer happening as of late last year.

3. Spice Girls Dolls: Wannabe Your Favorite Spice

Wikimedia Commons

If you were a fan of the Spice Girls, having their dolls was practically a requirement. Each doll was styled to look like your favorite member, from Sporty Spice to Scary Spice, complete with iconic outfits and accessories. These dolls weren’t just about collecting—they were about channeling your inner Spice Girl. Whether you rocked the sporty look of Mel C or embraced the bold fashion of Geri, the dolls made you feel like you were part of the global girl power movement. You could create your own concerts or have the dolls perform on stage, bringing the Spice Girls’ music and energy to life in your own home.

The dolls themselves were vibrant and full of personality, reflecting the unique styles of each Spice Girl. Every accessory added to the experience, from their platform shoes to their sparkly microphones. You could even swap outfits between the dolls, allowing for endless customization. The Spice Girls weren’t just a pop group—they were a cultural phenomenon. Owning their dolls was more than just having a toy; it was a symbol of your connection to the ’90s pop culture explosion. Playing with the dolls, you could live out your dreams of stardom and girl power, and there was nothing cooler than strutting around with your dolls in hand. This just showcased the impact that the Spice Girls had on the ’90s, according to the Guardian.

4. Beanie Babies: The Fad That Took Over the World

Flickr

Beanie Babies weren’t just plush toys—they were a collectible sensation. The ’90s were filled with kids (and adults) scrambling to catch them all, searching for the rarest of the Beanie Babies to add to their collection. Each one had its own name, backstory, and personality, which made them feel even more special. You could bond with your Beanie Baby in a way that was both unique and personal. They were small enough to carry around, and their soft, squishy bodies made them perfect for cuddling. But it wasn’t just about hugging these little critters; it was about owning something that might one day be worth a lot of money.

The excitement of hunting down limited edition Beanie Babies was real, especially when new ones were released at the stores. There were rumors of certain Beanie Babies becoming worth thousands of dollars, which kept the frenzy going strong. Everyone would discuss which ones were the rarest and most valuable, making the Beanie Babies world feel like an underground club of collectors. The problem was, once you collected a few, you were hooked—each Beanie Baby seemed to be cuter than the last. Looking back, it wasn’t just the cuteness that made Beanie Babies special, but the way they became a shared experience, something everyone could talk about and connect over. Fox gave an update on if any are worth anything today and the chances are your beloved Beanie Babies aren’t worth a lot of cash.

5. Furby: The Creepy Yet Cute Electronic Pet

PICRYL

Furby was the toy that everyone loved to hate—but no one could resist. It was a strange creature with large eyes, floppy ears, and a beak, and it could “talk” and interact with you in surprising ways. What made Furby so addictive was its ability to “learn” over time. When you first got it, it would speak only in a language that sounded like gibberish, but the more you played with it, the more it would pick up English phrases. People loved watching this little creature evolve, and they were both fascinated and frightened by its unpredictability. Furby became a toy that sparked conversations everywhere, from schoolyards to living rooms, and even though it had a slightly eerie quality, no one could get enough of it.

Furby’s true magic, though, lay in its ability to mimic real-life pets. It responded to your touch, voice, and actions in a way that felt surprisingly lifelike. It was the closest thing to owning a robot pet in the ’90s, and it captured the imagination of millions. However, as time passed, Furby became a little bit of a running joke, with many people mocking the strange sounds it made. Still, no one could deny how much fun it was to have one—whether you were in it for the novelty or for the sheer oddity of it all, Furby was the toy you couldn’t help but talk about. Don’t forget, there is a new Furby in town and the Verge gave their unbiased review of it.

6. Barbie Dream House: The Ultimate Dream Home

Flickr

Every girl in the ’90s dreamt of owning the iconic Barbie Dream House. It wasn’t just a dollhouse—it was a lifestyle. With its pink exterior and fancy, modern interior, it was everything you could want in a dream home. The house was three stories high, with a working elevator, a pool, and even a garage for Barbie’s convertible. Each room was filled with luxurious details, from the fully stocked kitchen to the glamorous bedroom. Playing with the Dream House wasn’t just about having Barbie live there—it was about imagining yourself living in that space. It was the type of play that encouraged daydreaming and creativity as you arranged and rearranged the furniture.

The Barbie Dream House became the ultimate backdrop for imaginative adventures. You could throw parties, design the rooms, and invite your friends over to play. With the wide variety of Barbie dolls and accessories available, your Dream House could be filled with endless possibilities. Barbie could be a doctor, a teacher, a rock star—anything you imagined. This toy was so iconic that it felt like a status symbol for girls who were serious about playing with their dolls. It wasn’t just a place for Barbie; it was a portal to a world where anything was possible, and the excitement of designing and playing with it was unbeatable.

7. Skip-It: The Toy That Got You Moving

Wikimedia Commons

Skip-It was the perfect toy for the girl who loved to be active, yet still wanted to have fun. This simple, yet addictive toy consisted of a plastic hoop that you slipped around your ankle, and a long string that allowed you to “skip” the toy over the ground by hopping around. The goal was to see how many times you could make it go around in a row without tripping. It was an easy way to get outside and burn off some energy, making it one of the most popular toys for summer playdates. You could challenge your friends to see who could keep their Skip-It going the longest, creating a friendly competition that kept you entertained for hours.

What made Skip-It so great was its accessibility. Unlike other toys that required a lot of setup, you could take your Skip-It anywhere—whether it was on the sidewalk, in the driveway, or at the park. The toy encouraged physical activity in a fun, non-competitive way, and it became a staple of ’90s outdoor play. Whether you were racing to see who could skip the fastest or just enjoying a casual session with your friends, Skip-It was the toy that made you feel like you were part of the “It” crowd. It may have seemed simple, but in the ’90s, it was the perfect blend of exercise and entertainment.

8. Lite-Brite: Where Light Meets Creativity

Flickr

Lite-Brite was a toy that allowed you to create glowing works of art with tiny, colorful pegs. The best part? You could create anything your imagination desired! You’d take the pegs and stick them into a grid, and when you turned on the light behind it, your creation would light up in beautiful, vibrant colors. Whether you followed the templates or made your own designs, Lite-Brite turned your creative ideas into a glowing masterpiece. It wasn’t just a toy—it was a way to express yourself and show off your artistic talents to friends and family.

Lite-Brite provided hours of fun, and it encouraged girls to explore their creative side. It wasn’t just about playing with the pegs; it was about experimenting with patterns, color combinations, and even creating intricate scenes or characters. You could spend hours on a single project, fine-tuning every little detail until it was perfect. The sense of accomplishment when your design lit up was a feeling like no other. Lite-Brite brought light and color into your world, and it became one of the most iconic creative toys of the ’90s. Every girl who had one knew how amazing it felt to create something that literally glowed with life.

9. Easy-Bake Oven: The Kitchen Toy That Was Actually Fun

Wikimedia Commons

The Easy-Bake Oven was the toy that made every girl feel like a chef. With its mini oven and easy-to-use mix packets, you could bake tiny cakes, cookies, and even brownies—all from the comfort of your own room. The best part? You didn’t need to be an expert in the kitchen to make something delicious. The oven itself was easy to use and operated with a light bulb, which kept it safe for kids to handle. It wasn’t just about baking—it was about the excitement of creating your own treats from scratch, with a little help from the magic of the Easy-Bake Oven.

Baking with the Easy-Bake Oven was an experience you could share with friends, too. You could host your own mini bake-offs or surprise your parents with freshly baked goodies. The toy wasn’t just a game—it was a learning experience, showing you how to follow instructions and measure ingredients. It was the perfect introduction to cooking, and it felt like a grown-up experience for girls who wanted to be just like their moms. Every time you baked something new, it felt like you were accomplishing something big, and you couldn’t wait to share it with everyone around you. The Easy-Bake Oven was the gateway to a lifetime of culinary fun and creativity.

10. Bead Mazes: Twist, Turn, and Move

Wikimedia Commons

Bead Mazes were a simple yet mesmerizing toy that kept you occupied for hours. The colorful beads slid along the wire, twisting and turning as you maneuvered them from one side to the other. It was a toy that required patience, concentration, and a little bit of skill. The challenge was getting each bead to follow the path you created, and there was a certain satisfaction in watching the beads move smoothly along the maze. The small, handheld nature of Bead Mazes made them easy to carry and play with anywhere, from school to car rides.

What made Bead Mazes even more captivating was their ability to engage both young minds and adults. The repetitive nature of guiding the beads provided a soothing experience, almost like a form of meditation. You could spend hours lost in the process of twisting and turning the beads, fully absorbed in the task at hand. It was one of those toys that you never really outgrew—it could be enjoyed by both younger and older kids alike. The challenge was always fresh, and each new twist and turn felt like an accomplishment. Bead Mazes may have been simple, but they gave you a sense of control and achievement, which made them irresistibly fun.

11. Giga Pets: The Rival to Tamagotchi

Wikipedia

If Tamagotchi was the original, Giga Pets were the worthy rival that every girl wanted to have. Just like Tamagotchi, Giga Pets were virtual pets that needed your constant care, feeding, and attention. However, Giga Pets offered different animals and some even had additional features like multiple games or the ability to evolve differently. While Tamagotchi may have been the “must-have” for many, owning a Giga Pet was a badge of honor, as it showed you were part of an even cooler trend. There was a certain pride in having one, as it was more than just a toy—it was a competition to see whose pet was the healthiest or most evolved.

What made Giga Pets unique was the variety of animals you could choose from. Whether you had a dog, cat, or even an alien, each one came with its own personality and quirks. They provided all the same joys and frustrations as Tamagotchi but had a bit more variety in how you interacted with them. Caring for a Giga Pet became a daily routine that you couldn’t ignore. Much like their counterpart, they encouraged you to be responsible while also offering moments of amusement. Giga Pets may not have had the same global impact as Tamagotchi, but for those who had them, they were just as beloved.

Scroll to Top